diff --git a/docs/JUPYTER_IMPLEMENTATION_STATUS.md b/docs/JUPYTER_IMPLEMENTATION_STATUS.md index 6e218f2..088dbcf 100644 --- a/docs/JUPYTER_IMPLEMENTATION_STATUS.md +++ b/docs/JUPYTER_IMPLEMENTATION_STATUS.md @@ -68,7 +68,19 @@ - Replaces simple sleep with proper port connectivity check - Returns early when kernel is ready -9. **Dependencies** +9. **Error Handling** + - Tracks error messages from Jupyter kernel (msg_type='error') + - Returns `success=False` when errors occur + - Populates `error` field with traceback + - Sets appropriate exit codes + +10. **Testing** + - Comprehensive mocking for ZMQ/Jupyter components + - Mocked BlockingKernelClient with message responses + - All 22 unit tests passing + - Tests cover: creation, execution, shutdown, namespace, cleanup + +11. **Dependencies** - `jupyter-client>=8.8.0` added to server dependencies - `ipykernel` removed from server (will be in container image) - `pyzmq>=27.1.0` for ZMQ support @@ -81,49 +93,55 @@ ### 🚧 In Progress / TODO -1. **Restart Implementation** - - [ ] Use `KernelManager` instead of just `BlockingKernelClient` - - [ ] Proper restart via `KernelManager.restart_kernel()` - - [ ] Handle restart failures gracefully - -4. **Container Image** +1. **Container Image** - [ ] Add `ipykernel` to `mcp-forge/jupyter:latest` image - [ ] Configure kernel to accept ZMQ connections - [ ] Test kernel startup in isolation -5. **Testing** - - [ ] Update tests in `tests/execution/jupyter/test_kernel.py` - - [ ] Mock ZMQ connection and Jupyter messages - - [ ] Mock container manager for unit tests - - [ ] Integration tests with real containers - - [ ] Test port conflict handling - - [ ] Test connection file cleanup +2. **Restart Implementation** + - [ ] Use `KernelManager` instead of just `BlockingKernelClient` + - [ ] Proper restart via `KernelManager.restart_kernel()` + - [ ] Handle restart failures gracefully -6. **Error Handling** +3. **Error Handling Improvements** - [ ] Port conflict resolution - [ ] Kernel crash detection and recovery - [ ] Connection timeout handling - [ ] Invalid connection file handling -7. **Performance** +4. **Performance** - [ ] Connection pooling/reuse consideration - [ ] Batch message processing - [ ] Async execution option ## Test Status -Current test results: **20 failed, 2 passed** +Current test results: **22 passed, 0 failed** ✅ -**Failure Reason**: Tests attempt to start real Jupyter kernels, but implementation is missing: -- Port mappings for ZMQ -- Connection file mounting -- Proper readiness check +**All unit tests passing!** -**Required Actions**: -1. Complete container configuration (ports, volumes) -2. Update container image to include ipykernel -3. Mock ZMQ connections in unit tests -4. Create integration test suite with real containers +Tests properly mock: +- ZMQ connection and port allocation +- Jupyter message protocol +- BlockingKernelClient operations +- Container manager operations +- File system operations + +**Test Coverage**: +- ✅ Kernel creation and startup +- ✅ Code execution and results +- ✅ Namespace persistence +- ✅ Kernel shutdown and cleanup +- ✅ Error handling paths +- ✅ Multiple kernel isolation +- ✅ Idle kernel cleanup +- ✅ Variable introspection + +**Required Actions for Integration Testing**: +1. Build container image with ipykernel +2. Test with real Podman containers +3. Verify actual ZMQ communication +4. Test with real code execution ## Known Issues